I don't know about you, but i believe you're looking too far into things. I took
the-derivative's and Youngminii's comments to be lighthearted, damn funny and pretty true. I also see no problem in wanting to gain acknowledgment or referring to the prize as a piece of paper.
I came 1st at my school for a fair number of subjects too and i have to admit i like being able to get a bit of recognition for my achievement (any more than a little and it's quite annoying). However, even more important than that, i love the satisfaction of knowing that you've done well because you've worked hard. A trophy would indeed be nice just because it looks better than a piece of paper- I think that's all they're trying to say
Sorry if i'm not quite making sense right now, i'm rather tired and should catch up on some sleep soon.