Anthony Callea vs Casey Donovan (2 Viewers)

[Fry]

i hate to admit this but Anthony's new single ain't that bad..

 

[Sparcod]

I'm a casey fan I love her second single 'whats goin' on?' I like it better than her debut single. I was goin to audition 4 the 2nd series of idol but decided not to due to yr 12 and other things. Not sure if I'll audition this yr or not.

you shouldve auditioned in idol1 2 years ago....
if you are going to audition.. GOOD LUCK

 

[marchetta]

I think Casey won because she was the underdog, and everybody praises the underdog. But I still think Anthony should've won....
I remember at the start of the finale show, somebody said they prefere Casey over Anthony because they're sick of pop music, and there should be more rock music and I was like thinking, 'well why do you watch idol? Idol is all about pop music...like duh.

 

[melsc]

Well said .

 

[champ_sammy_19]

you shouldve auditioned in idol1 2 years ago....
if you are going to audition.. GOOD LUCK

Thanks!!

 

[Sparcod]

did someone say 'big girls with attitude'?
that's funny

 

[marchetta]

The fact that some teenage 16 year old poser-goth-evanescence-style-fat-bitch-with-an-attitude is the "idol" of our country makes me want to stab someone in the face.





I choose Anthony.

Even though I don't like Casey, calling her 'fat' is just going to the extreme.

 

[Sparcod]

Even though I don't like Casey, calling her 'fat' is just going to the extreme.

she is fat if not fatter compared to others say, those in the final 12

 

[stainmepink]

anthony is doing heaps good
whats with that?
the runner up always does better then the winner
like guy sebastian and shannon knolls
shannon knolls is doing heaps better
from what i see etc

yeh but thats only because guy went overseas to promote himself why shannon stayed in aussie. so thats why we hear so much of shannon.

and about casey i dunno why the fuck she won. do you think maybe the voting was rigged?

ie if anthony came first ppl would buy his albums but if casey was 2nd no one would really buy them. but making her first would give the people the impression that she was good so they would go out buy her albums and be dissapointed, but still buy anthony's album. and the thing about anthony is that he can actually hold an interview, unlike freaking casey.

 

[stainmepink]

she is fat if not fatter compared to others say, those in the final 12

true that the final 12 where a bit fatter than last yeras

 

[melsc]

yeh but thats only because guy went overseas to promote himself why shannon stayed in aussie. so thats why we hear so much of shannon.

and about casey i dunno why the fuck she won. do you think maybe the voting was rigged?

ie if anthony came first ppl would buy his albums but if casey was 2nd no one would really buy them. but making her first would give the people the impression that she was good so they would go out buy her albums and be dissapointed, but still buy anthony's album. and the thing about anthony is that he can actually hold an interview, unlike freaking casey.

Agreed

I think she won much like kurt nelson on WI as she was just "a flavor or the month" i dont mean to be horrible and i respect her, but people liked her coz she was the underdog, now no one cares anymore...I think she was trying TOO hard 2 be different

 

[stainmepink]

and also i hated how mark holden gave her so many fucken touch downs. SHES NOT THAT GOOD MARK FUCKEN HOLDEN. urgh no one gives a shit. if only shed just stop making albums already

 

[Sparcod]

yeh, i am a bit slow
but who is the third idol judge replacing dicko?

 

[stainmepink]

kyle sandilands from 2day fm

i am right?

 

[melsc]

yep...and dont get me started on his g/f song

 

[spell check]

kyle sandilands from 2day fm

i am right?

ahaha another talentless fat guy with bad hair

 

[Sparcod]

kyle sandilands?
from 2day fm?

 

[nicko88]

Yes, that would be right. Kyle Sandilands is the new idol judge. And by taking on this new, much anticipated role, I think he's making career suicide. If he doesn't get enough bad reviews for himself on his radio show, then think just what will happen when he's on this show?

Anything's possible.

Oh, and...both are crap.

 

[Sparcod]

i didn't go for casey...
i just hoped that courtney and anthony would be final two

 

[wanton-wonton]

there both absolutely horrible in my opinion

I'd like to see you do better.