i thought it was alright, nowhere near as good as "the nightmare before christmas", but good fun none the less.
i however have to disagree with the person who disliked the musical parts. i thought the first underworld scene with "bonejangles" (great name!) was excellent.
the ending was rather hastily piled together, and i didnt find any of the characters endearing except emily (which is strange because i usually dislike bonham carter).
i cant really explain it, but the film lacked heart i think. while the characters, songs and plot of nightmare was full and fast, this film had rather contrived and predictable jokes and events.
i loved the visual aspect however, and the difference between the boring victorian existence and the colourful 1920's underworld.