Lord of the rings book (1 Viewer)

[Benny_]

Originally posted by Lexicographer
Even in the uber-l33t extended edition (which I own ) Tom Bombadil isn't even mentioned. We can yet hope, however, that the battle will be multiplied in coolness for the megaDVD of ROTK

Myeas.. I'm not a LotR fan, but I must say the entirety of the Minas Tirith arc of the film was wonderfully done. Then again, it's so well done that I'm doubtful of whether they cut anything out

 

[Enlightened_One]

I'm certain they cut out a scene with Saruman in it, but that's right at the beginning, way before the battle of Minas Tirith

 

[Lexicographer]

I haven't bothered re-reading it yet. I just can't spare the time. Maybe during VC week.

 

[KfWang]

hhhmm i reakcon the book was a lot better too, i mean given the time limit of a film peter jackson did absolute magic.
still... i wanted 2 c all the rangers fight and stuff, and how saruman got his butt kicked... i also didnt like the ending of the fight at gondor, how all the ghosts came and then kiled everything ruined a good fight scene.. well not really, but just didnt add onto it
im starting 2 read the books again...

 

[sweetcherry]

The first book is good... havent read the rest yet

 

[**freakstar87**]

i heard that the scene with saruman might (i mean might) appear in the extended edition. i hope it's true.
the books rock!!! didn't get the whole tom bombadil bit but still it's worth that he can be included for around 5 minutes in the 1st film at least.