--- The solution
I'd say keep the gift, tell him you're a great guy but he's not what you're looking for/you're not interested/wouldn't work out/etc. Put the foot down!.
--- The reactions
If he's a 'man', he'll take it stoically. But overall he'll get over it, it was only 1 date after all.
If not and he starts to cry, well obviously he's a bit of a pussy isn't he?.
I'd say keep the gift, tell him you're a great guy but he's not what you're looking for/you're not interested/wouldn't work out/etc. Put the foot down!.
--- The reactions
If he's a 'man', he'll take it stoically. But overall he'll get over it, it was only 1 date after all.
If not and he starts to cry, well obviously he's a bit of a pussy isn't he?.